Can I pre-order a pie or pie in a jar on the same day and pick up?

All orders must be placed 24 hours in advance and are available for pick up by 10am. the following day.

I ordered a pie and no longer want it , can I cancel?

All pies are made to order and are non-refundable.

I ordered a pie for pick but I would like to change the pick up date/time, can I change the date?

As all pies are made to order and to ensure freshness pick up dates cannot be changed; however, pick up time may be adjusted within our hours of operation.

Can I just come in and purchase a pie?

Have patience. At this time Kessler Pies only provides online orders

What do I do with the awesome pie pan i received when i purchased your amazing pie?

Keep it for your baking enjoyment or bring it back to us and receive a $2.00 discount on your next pie order.